CBC Radio One
Image of a manuscript   Image of DaVinci's Vitruvian Man (Man of Perfect Proportions)
  Image of host Paul Kennedy  

Host
About the Show
Schedule
Past Shows
Ideas In The Afternoon
Audio
Podcast
Features
Massey Lectures
CDs and Tapes
Submissions
Contact Us


 

 

 

 
Join host Paul Kennedy for Ideas
 

Features

Danielle Pagano (centre) with her half-sister, Ryann, and donor dad, Jeffrey and his dogs.

Listen to Episode 1
(.ram file runs: 54:00)

Listen to Episode 2
(.ram file runs: 54:00)

RealPlayer branding icon RealPlayer is required to listen to audio files. Download the RealPlayer plug-in for your browser

Sperm donation has proven to be a Pandora's Box. The vast majority of donor dads do not want to be found. In rare cases some children are seeking and finding dad and half-siblings in the process. Science journalist Alison Motluk explores the complex portrait of the brave new family.

Artificial insemination is creating new families, and new kinds of stories. The first recorded case was in 1884, when a wealthy Philadelphia couple who was having trouble conceiving, looked to their doctor for help. Without their consent, the doctor secretly conducted an experiment. He chloroformed the woman, and then persuaded his best-looking medical student to donate his seed, and it was injected into the uterus. The woman got pregnant. Twenty-five years later, the medical secret became public and was met with disbelief and outrage. But within a decade or two, artificial insemination had become a treatment for infertility.

In the early days, the procedure was arranged – discreetly through a woman’s fertility doctor. Couples didn’t ask questions about who the man was. And they were advised to keep quiet. By the end of the 1980’s, artificial insemination was becoming big business. Sperm was frozen and banked and a “donor” could be selected from a catalogue. But still the procedure remained secretive.

Today, it’s estimated there could be over one million children conceived through donor insemination. Now, great waves of these children are young adults – and they’re telling us things we never realized. First and foremost, genes do matter - despite what doctors and parents and donors believed. Many offspring genuinely want to know where they came from and who these mystery men are.

Kathleen LaBounty
Kathleen LaBounty

Kathleen LaBounty was 8 years old when her mother told her that she’d been conceived by artificial insemination and that the father she was growing up with was not biologically related to her. Her genetic father, an anonymous sperm donor, would never be known.

Kathleen was conceived back in the days of fresh donations. A man simply dropped off his sample a few hours before the insemination was to take place. Often, would-be parents didn’t even choose the donors – although Kathleen’s mother did make a special request for one with blue eyes. Because this was considered a “treatment” for infertility, records about these men were scant, if they were kept at all. But Kathleen wants to find this man, her biological father.

All she has to go on is that he probably attended Baylor College of Medicine in 1981 and he probably has blue eyes. So she has photocopied pictures of every male graduate from the Baylor College of Medicine between 1979 and 1984 and has systematically contacted them.

Ryan and Wendy Kramer
Ryan and Wendy Kramer

Until recently, every search for a sperm donor or half-sibling was a solitary one like this. But in 2003, Wendy Kramer and her teenage son, Ryan, created the Donor Sibling Registry. This is a website designed to help donor-conceived people find their relatives. Over 9,000 people are now members of the DSR and almost 4,000 matches have been made since it started.

Danielle Pagano (top photo), for instance, found her half-sister, JoEllen, in 2005. Since then, she has found out about several other half-siblings. Several of them even met up in New York. Then, in February, 2007, her donor father made himself known. Danielle flew out to meet him in early summer.

Every family tree has an unexpected branch or two. But sperm donation takes this to a whole new level, creating complex family webs. Half-siblings bonding as true siblings. Mothers getting to know each other because they have the same sperm donor. Offspring tracking down and meeting their biological fathers. These family units are so new, it’s hard to even know what to call them.

- Alison Motluk


RESOURCES

Books

Everything Conceivable: How Assisted Reproduction is Changing Men, Women and the World
, by Liz Mundy, published by Knopf, 2007.

The Genius Factory: The Curious History of the Nobel Prize Sperm Bank, by David Plotz, published by Random House, 2005.

Experiences of Donor Conception: Parents, Offspring and Donors through the Years by Caroline Lorbach, published by Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2003.

Mommies, Daddies, Donors, Surrogates: Answering Tough Questions & Building Strong Families by Diane Ehrensaft, published by The Guilford Press, 2005.

Who Am I? Experiences of Donor Conception by Dr. Alexina McWhinnie, published by Idreos Education Trust, 2006.

Behind Closed Doors: Moving Beyond Secrecy & Shame edited by Mikki Morrissette & the Donor Sibling Registry, published by Be-Mondo Publishing, 2006.

Having Your Baby Through Egg Donation by Ellen Sarasohn Glazer, published by Perspective Press, 2005.

Let Me Explain: A Story about Donor Insemination, by Jane T. Schnitter, published by Perspective Press, 1995.

My Story/Our Story, published by the Donor Conception Network.

Telling & Talking About Donor Conception: A Guide for Parents by the Donor Conception Network.

Websites

The Donor Sibling Registry

Infertility Network

Donor Conception Network

TangledWebs UK

News Group for People Conceived via Artificial Insemination

CBC does not endorse the content of external sites. Links will open in a new browser window.

 

Back to Top