Does this study make me look fat?
- August 29, 2006 4:50 PM |
- By Peter Hadzipetros
There's been a whack of studies over the past couple of months looking at the state of our waistlines — and our (mis)perceptions of them.
The only good news is most of us understand that obesity is a big problem that’s only getting bigger.
In Britain, a government study predicted that by 2010, nearly one in five girls between age two and 10 will be obese — and that a third of adult men will be, too. Right now, one in four British men is considered obese.
Earlier this month, the Canadian Medical Association found that nine per cent of Canadian parents thought their kids were overweight or obese. StatsCanada Figures show that 26 per cent of children are obese or overweight. Obesity, the agency says “results when people consume far more calories than they work off each day.”
Back in April, the Pew Research Center released its survey, Americans see weight problems everywhere but in the mirror. It found that 90 per cent of Americans agreed that most Americans are too fat – but only 40 per cent believed themselves to be overweight. U.S. government figures suggest that 60 per cent of Americans could use to shed some weight — and that half were obese.
The Pew study also found that Americans tend to perceive themselves as taller and thinner than they are.
It’s this perception thing that’s got me wondering. Most of us have no idea how many calories we take in — and how many we burn during the course of a day.
Most of us overestimate what we burn during exercise and underestimate how many calories we consume. Yeah, sampling the sauce while you’re cooking counts. Making sure it’s just right while it simmers away can really add up.
A middle-aged guy like me who weighs 183 pounds and spends much of the day at a computer only needs about 2,600 calories a day to keep the machinery of life going according to this calculator. Toss in an hour run at a 7:30 per mile pace, and I’ve earned the right to consume another 1,267 guilt-free calories.
What’s that – maybe three slices of pizza?
Trouble is, I’ll eat four.
Categories
All News blogs
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Back of the Pack
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Recent Entries
- The rewards and risks of extreme exercise
- It's rare that someone dies running a marathon or half marathon. Extraordinarily rare when three people die. Yet that's what happened in Detroit, Sunday, Oct. 18, 2009. Within 16 minutes, three men collapsed and died while running the half marathon... Continue reading this post
- The golden age of running
- For those of us who like to lace up a pair of over-priced running shoes and move one foot in front of the other a little more quickly than most people would like to, this is the best time of... Continue reading this post
- Late night calories could pack bigger punch for your paunch
- We've all pretty much accepted the notion that if we burn as many calories as we consume, our weight will remain stable. Add some exercise to the mix and your body will burn more than it takes in and you'll... Continue reading this post
Comments (11)
Okay, so here is my problem with this stuff. According to BMI I am borderline obese (BMI = 27 and one calculator told me that was obese). Then I do the waist measurement test and I am fine.
Then I look at my lifestyle. I am healthy, don't eat "far too many calories to burn off" because I have been this size since puberty. And I am in better shape than many normal BMI people I know. And yet, I my weight is going to be a drain on society for years to come - worse than if I smoked. Give me a break!
183 pounder who does not move much needs 2600 calaories?
I don't think it is that simple. It depends on few factors. Muscle to fat ratio is one of them. Muscles need energy, fat is energy. Some people burn more than others naturally.
Life style is another factor. Even simple walk in the evening instead of watching TV makes a difference.
Also, when we sleep energy usage by our bodies decreases by half. Average person will burn 50 calaries while sleeping and about 100 when awake. It increases when when are more active.
To sumarrize, a couch potato of a size of 170 pounds, sleeping 8 hours a night will need about 2000 calories in 24 hour period. Anything more will be deposited as fat. 1 pound of fat is about 3500 calories, meaning that if consume 500 calories to many in a day, we can gain a pound in a week.
Another factor to consier is how fast certain foods can be digested (transformed to sugar). If very quickly, like sugar - be ready to get running right away or it will go right on your butt. Learn about glycemic index.
Have fun..... Jerry
Being fit and healty is not just a measure of looking like a GQ or Shape cover model. BMI is only part of the equation in accessing health and fitness. Eating the right foods, getting exercise and care for yourself is the answer - sorry there is no magic pill. Eat pizza and cheesecake, just do not eat it everyday and the whole thing.
The thing that gets me about our children becoming obese is that some parents still find it shocking. You mean all those hours I ALLOW my child to sit inactive will actually set them up for weight and health problems? Go figure! Or wow I had no idea all that fast food and packaged stuff I feed them daily was bad for them! Who knew? Also we work full time and have 3 little children. On any given night you can find us all in the backyard playing or out for a walk or skating in the winter....sometimes we're the only ones out there. I think it's time to stop blaming video games and technology and look at who's allowing it to occur.
Yes, it's a good thing that "most of us understand obesity is a big problem". A good thing for people making their living promoting social hysteria over health. A good thing for neurotics with a compulsion to mind their neighbor's business. A good thing for journalists desperate to have a "life-saving" crusade to call their own.
Of course obesity is a problem these days.
Things should be changing though, according to all the low-fat food alternatives which are now available.
Low-fat ice cream & frozen-yogourt, those silly flavored waters, etc... I think we should worry about what was done to these low-fat products to actually make them low fat?
I'm rather be a little obese, then consume tons of aspartame and the other replacement additives in foods and beverages. Lean and full of cancer, no way. We just need to be healty for our body type. Eating well and exercising regularly should keep us going strong, no?
The whole theory of the BMI in my opinion needs to get tossed out the window. The index does not account for muscle mass, bone structure or other differences in people.
An acquaintance of mine is in extremely good physical condition, 6pack abs and firmly muscled throughout. However, due to the additional "weight" he carries due to his muscle he is classified as "obese". However a "thin" person on this scale is considered "healthy" no matter that they may not eat properly and get little to no cardiovascular exercise. These people could be malnourished and or borderline anorexic. Stick thin does not necessarily equate to health.
A proper indication of your health should take into account all aspects of a healthy body, fat deposits on the body, cardiovascular health etc...not merely a height to weight ratio
The rise in obesity in North America can be directly linked to the rise of fast and processed food, the decline of neighborhood grocery stores, and the corporatization of the global food supply.
If possible - eat local, eat whole foods, shop for groceries often and stay away from sugar and refined flour. You will no longer be obese.
http://junkandcrapamen.blogspot.com/
We and our children are not becoming obese because we eat too much “fatty food,” we are becoming obese because we eat too much non-food. Our weight problems - and most of our health problems - can be traced to the huge amount of stuff we eat that has little or no nutritional value. It’s not the fat in our hamburgers we need to be worried about, or the cheese on our pizzas. It’s the polymerized vegetable oil we’re putting in our stomachs every time we eat a french fry, and of course the load of sugar we get in every soft drink. These are the substances that are not just worthless but dangerous as well.
We once ate low-cost, high-nutrient foods that provided us with all the protein, carbohydrates, fats, sugars, vitamins and minerals we needed in exactly the right proportions. We now eat high-profit, low-nutrient food products that leave us forever hungry, never satisfied, and thus always poking around in the fridge.
To the extent that we replace small amounts of high-nutrient foods with larger amounts of low-nutrient foods, we invite obesity, heart disease, cancer and diabetes. We needn’t look far for proof. The evidence is all around us.
As a Canadian living overseas one thing that has struck me is the food intake. The Scottish diet is based mostly on deep fried pies, chips, fast food, sausage, and beer. Not suprisingly people here tend to be overweight. Go over to Italy, people eat the same amount of calories, but in complex carbohydrates and vegetables. The result is more averaged weight people. I don't think it takes a degree in kinesiology or nutrition to understand that fat makes you fat. Simple sugars that spend a half hour in our body then are used up make you fat. It's about having a little will power and going for a walk. One style of food i.e. processed food cannot be blamed for obesity, it's a life style change. I challenge anyone who does not have time or energy to go for a walk to try it for a couple of weeks and see what happens.
I agree with many of the comments made, it seems like people really are educated on the reasons for obesity in norht america. we absolutely are slaves to the corporations that have massive profits and cost next to nothing to make, since these foods are of zero nutritional value. i weighed 240 at 6'0 and 23yrs old 3yrs ago. today i am a very healthy 180lbs 26yrs old and i lost it simply by eating 6 small meals a day, cutting out carbonated POP and fast food, eating tons of fruits and vegetable and whole wheat breads and pastas. if only everyone would take the initiative to change their diets and not simply complain they cant lose weight by simply running 20minutes on a treadmill and picking up a few dumbbells. eat organic as much as possible and stay away from the false "whole grain" labels by the cereal companies! :)