CBC News: the fifth estate - Lost in the Struggle

Note: You are viewing the unstyled version of CBC.ca because you can not see our css files, or because you do not have a standards-compliant browser or you are a mobile user.

Orginally Aired October 4,
2006
Updated January 31, 2007

REPORTER: Gillian Findlay
PRODUCER/DIRECTOR: Tamar Weinstein
PRODUCER: Jennifer Fowler

WEB EXCLUSIVE:
THE HOOD

Read about the history of the Jane/Finch neighbourhood. MORE

LOST IN THE STRUGGLE

The fifth estate wanted to know why young men in some neighbourhoods of Canadian cities are drawn to a culture of violence. A culture where drug sales are often a source of income, friendships are defended with weapons, and a deadly dispute can start with a disrespectful glance.

Rather than accessing this world through the police or social workers, producers wanted to document the lives of the young men in their own voices. To learn what options are available to a young person who grows up in a culture where loyalty is determined by whom you're willing to protect. And to understand how they get left behind by the systems of education, social services and justice that are supposed to protect them.

Local filmmakers

To get the access needed to tell this story, producers enlisted two young filmmakers. Paul Nguyen and Mark Simms grew up in Toronto's Jane and Finch neighbourhood, an area that has waged a decades-long battle against a reputation for violence and hopelessness.

Chuckie and Burnz met through their common love of rap music.

Simms and Nguyen introduced producers at the fifth estate to three young men who have all lived with violence, at times as the victim, at times the perpetrator. Phong Nguyen, aka Chuckie, Andrew Burnett, aka Burnz and Albi Aziz, aka Freshy, all grew up in Jane and Finch.

One has lived by the gun from a young age. Another desperately wants to get out of the cycle of violence and retribution but doesn't know how. The other aspires to a criminal life despite the better options available to him.

The fifth estate, together with Simms and Nguyen as film crew, spent 10 months following Chuckie's, Burnz' and Freshy's lives, from their criminal exploits and encounters with the justice system to their relationships with family, friends, and each other.

The turns their lives took, the dilemmas they faced and the decisions they made formed the narrative of the story. The stories that unfold are of struggle: to succeed when poverty, lack of education and opportunity pull you down; to escape from the only life you've known; and to make positive choices in the face of anger and aimlessness.

Update

Since the fifth estate first broadcast Lost in the Struggle, Burnz has become a father. His son, Treshawn Burnett, was born on January 13.

Freshy isn't Freshy anymore. He goes by Albi now. He dropped his street name and says he dropped the street action as well. He's in his last year of high school and is thinking of studying criminology at university.

Chuckie is still in school and he's thinking of joining the army. This coming fall, he will meet a key qualification. At that point, assuming all goes well, Chuckie will have been off probation for a full 18 months. The fifth estate will keep in touch with Burnz, Albi, and Chuckie and will report back.

^TOP