Note: You are viewing the unstyled version of CBC.ca because you can not see our css files, or because you do not have a standards-compliant browser or you are a mobile user.

Welcome to CBC.ca


CBC News: the fifth estate - More about the fifth estatesubscribe to our e-mail newslettercontact us
Fasten your Seatbelts: Is the billions of dollars we've spent on airport security since 9/11 worth it's price tag?
Aired November 9, 2005
Updated November 22, 2006

WATCH the fifth estate ONLINE

Watch this story online. (Runs 40:29)
Watch the update (Runs 8:48)
REPORTER: Hana Gartner
PRODUCER: Marie Caloz

UPDATE
In response to the fifth estate's story Transport Minister Jean Lapierre promised a review of the Canadian Air Transport Security Authority. More

WEB EXCLUSIVE

the fifth estate asked
Steve Elson to visit Canada and assess some of our airports.

Read more of his interview with the fifth estate.
Bookmark this page | E-mail to a friend
BEN-GURION AIRPORT IN ISREAL
The level of threat from terrorism is different in Canada and Israel. But, because Israel's Ben-Gurion Airport may be the most secure airport in the world, it's instructive to understand how security there works. Israel has been perfecting its airport security for more than 30 years.

TERRORIST ATTACKS AT BEN-GURION
The country's wake-up call came in May 1972 when there were two terrorist attacks on the airport. On May 9, 1972, two men hijacked a Sabena Airlines passenger plane at Lod Airport (since renamed Ben-Gurion Airport) in Tel Aviv. Ninety passengers and 10 crew were held hostage for 23 hours before twelve Israeli soldiers, disguised as maintenance workers, stormed the plane.

The second attack occurred later that month, on May 29, 1972. In what became known as the Lod Airport Massacre three members of the terrorist group, Japanese Red Army, arrived at the airport aboard an Air France flight from Paris. Once inside the airport they grabbed automatic firearms from their carry-on cases and fired at airport staff and visitors. In the end, 26 people died and 80 people were injured.

"We are not talking theoretically about terrorism and security," says Zeev Sarig, who was at Lod Airport the day of the killings and is now Managing Director of the airport. "We saw, we felt it and we are acting accordingly to prevent it."

Ben-Gurion airport Security at the Ben-Gurion Airport in Israel emphasizes intelligence gathering.
THE NEW SECURITY POLICY
Today, Ben-Gurion Airport is heavily guarded, every visitor scrutinized. There are armed guards at the entry and extra fencing and surveillance cameras everywhere. The airport grounds, mail, cargo and employees all fall under intense scrutiny. All vehicles traveling on airport roads must stop at booths staffed by security people.

Once inside the terminal, security is almost invisible. But it's omnipresent. Here, no one gets through an airport door without permission. All people and luggage go through high-tech screening machines. But Avi Rimon, head of security at Ben-Gurion Airport, says technology is only part of the puzzle. "Technology detects abilities of a terrorist and does not detect his intent," Rimon says.

That's why Ben-Gurion Airport security staff emphasize intelligence gathering in security. Every passenger going through Ben-Gurion Airport undergoes questioning. Israel won't divulge the specifics of its process, but it will say that screeners ask a multitude of questions fitted to each individual. The questions allow screeners to assess behaviour patterns. The screeners, most of whom are young people who have finished their compulsory military duty, learn exactly what to look for and how to rate a passenger as a possible threat. The more suspicious a passenger, the more intensively screened that person will be.

THE RICHARD REID EXAMPLE
In North America, the emphasis is more on finding the weapon.
Ben-Gurion airport Israeli secuity screeners were suspicious of Richard Reid and placed an armed Air Marshall beside him on the flight.

Consider the case of Richard Reid. He's the man who tried to blow up an American Airlines flight bound for Miami from Paris in December 2001. Passengers restrained him when he tried to ignite his shoelaces. Screening machines had failed to detect the explosive chemicals Reid was carrying in his shoes and he was allowed to board the plane.

But, earlier that year, Israel had also encountered Richard Reid. Scanning machines at Ben-Gurion Airport did not detect any explosive chemicals on Reid, but Israeli security screeners were soon suspicious of him. In the end, they only allowed Reid to board his flight after moving him to the rear of the aircraft and placing an armed Air Marshall beside him. Reid could not make a move.

Critics of the Israeli security system argue that the intrusive questioning at Ben-Gurion Airport often amounts to racial profiling. But, Israel argues the questioning is necessary for effective airport security and the safety of travellers.

^TOP