Main: Becoming Ayden
Ayden's Story
The Medical Opinion
Life after the Transition
Resources
Becoming Ayden - The Medical Opinion
Bookmark this page | E-mail to a friend
ORIGINALLY AIRED: October 13, 2004
THE EXPERT OPINION
Aaron Devor - Ray Blanchard - Leslie Shanks - Pierre Brassard

PHOTO GALLERY
A seventeen year-old makes the transition from Adina to Ayden. Follow some of the important milestones in her journey.

LAUNCH PHOTOGALLERY

Transsexualism - also known as Gender Identity Disorder or Gender Dysphoria - is considered a psychiatric disorder by the World Health Organization and the American Psychiatric Association. The disorder causes mental distress. Transsexuals will go to great lengths to alter their sex to correspond with their gender.

Gender experts have come up with a set of guidelines called
The Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association's Standards of Care For Gender Identity Disorder. This universal consensus gives medical professionals direction on how to manage patients seeking hormones and surgery. The Standards of Care advise three months of psychotherapy and that patients live as the opposite sex for a full year before even considering surgery. But they are only recommendations. (see the guidelines )


Aaron Devor says that 'sex is between the legs, and gender is between the ears.'

Aaron Devor

Aaron Devor is the Dean of Graduate Studies and a Professor of Sociology at the University of Victoria. He is an international expert in gender and sexuality. (see his homepage )

Devor has no doubts about the benefits of cosmetic surgery in treating transsexuals.

Aaron Devor: "
Cosmetic surgery is done widely in society and it's done precisely for this reason, to relieve mental anguish. Everybody who goes in for a nip and tuck is going to go in because they think they'll feel better."

But he says that it's not possible to change sex completely.

"There's a whole variety of core elements that are part of what makes a person male or female that are not affected by the sex change procedures. We don't have the technology to affect people on that core level. However if you look at the feel and the smell and the shape of the body, we can change that quite successfully."

^Top


Dr. Ray Blanchard has studied gender for about twenty-five years and advises a more cautious approach.
Ray Blanchard

Psychologist Ray Blanchard is in charge of Canada's most established gender clinic at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health in Toronto. He has been studying transsexuals for about twenty-five years. He says that we know more about how to treat transsexualism than what causes it.

Ray Blanchard: "
If people are desperately unhappy right now and there is nothing else to do besides sex reassignment, then I think this is the best we can do and what we should do. Cosmetic surgery can help people lead much happier and productive lives."

His clinic sees about fifty patients a year and he rejects 75% of them.

Ray Blanchard: "
We are not trying to encourage people to have sex reassignment surgery. On the contrary, we encourage people to try to make an adjustment to their biological gender."

He advises a cautious approach.

Ray Blanchard:"
I think it would be preferable if everyone who wants to make a decision about having parts of their body removed or altered should have some kind of screening procedure. If not ours, then something similar to make sure that is what they want before they take any irreversible steps."

^Top


Dr. Leslie Shanks is a family practitioner who treats many patients wanting to change their sex at Toronto's Sherbourne Health Centre.
Leslie Shanks

Doctor Leslie Shanks is the Medical Director at Toronto's Sherbourne Health Centre. The clinic sees more than 200 transgendered patients.

Leslie Shanks: "
Certainly we have been shocked since we've opened our trans programming here at the number of people we're seeing."

Shanks doesn't believe Ayden is too young to start hormone therapy. Her goal is to reduce the suffering of her patients.

Leslie Shanks: "We're not talking about a political or philosophical choice. We're talking about an intense distress with the body that they were born in."

She says the bottom line is a person's right to make informed decisions about their health.


Leslie Shanks: "I would say no if I felt it wasn't a gender identity issue. I would say no if I felt they had a medical contraindication to it or if there was a psychiatric contraindication to that."

^Top



Dr. Pierre Brassard is one of the top cosmetic surgeons in the world specializing in sex reassignment surgery.
Pierre Brassard

Dr. Pierre Brassard is a cosmetic surgeon at a private hospital in Montreal, Quebec. It is the only private clinic in Canada specializing in sex reassignment surgery. The clinic has a waiting list more than a year long with patients coming from all over the world. (see the website )

He says the clinic is doing approximately two hundred and forty male-to-female genital surgeries and ten female-to-male genital surgeries a year. Penises are much more complex to construct than vaginas.

Pierre Brassard: "
It's not a life saving procedure so I don't save lives. But that's what I hear all the time. You saved my life."

"When they (patients) come they really need the surgery. And the surgery is really important to them and for most of them after the surgery they're much better.

PRINTABLE VERSION

NOTE: The CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites. All links will open in a new browser window.

BACK TO the fifth estate

^TOP

the fifth estate: BECOMING AYDEN
ORIGINALLY AIRED: Wednesday October 13, 2004 at 9pm on CBC-TV
Ayden's Story - The Expert Opinion - Life after the Transition - Resources
Jobs | Contact Us | Help - RSS
Terms of Use | Privacy | Copyright | Other Policies
Copyright © CBC 2004