Chocolate in the schools
- November 10, 2009 11:03 AM |
- By Kevin Yarr
by Kevin Yarr, CBCNews.ca
A surprising controversy erupted last week when it was suggested that Prince Edward Island should subsidize the price of chocolate milk in its schools.
Long condemned as a candy bar in a carton, chocolate milk is now more commonly viewed by nutritionists as almost as good as unflavoured milk, containing all the same nutrients but with a little bit of sugar added.
And so came the suggestion for a subsidy, in a bid to prompt more children to drink more milk. The government has subsidized white milk through the P.E.I. School Milk Foundation since the 1980s.
Several schools and the Health Eating Alliance are in favour of the change, but the School Milk Foundation says it hasn't got the money.
Then people started to comment on CBC's web story, and it was not favourable. Comments abounded from the sugar-is-poison camp, and there was a significant contingent from the soy milk brigade as well.
"Milk is for baby cows, not kids!" wrote someone with the nickname of girsharmony.
"Eat properly and you have no need for milk! That stuff is full of nasty hormones and chemicals anyway, I'd rather give a kid pop."
It's always difficult to judge what people are really thinking about a story. It's easy to be fooled when dozens post negative comments, forgetting that thousands of people read it without commenting. A voluntary poll is hardly more scientific, but a reader poll is currently running with close to 80 per cent agreeing it's a good idea to subsidize chocolate milk.
But the debate did get me thinking: just how much sugar is in chocolate milk? Some commenters were even comparing it to an Oh Henry bar. Is that fair?
Well, it depends. Sugar in chocolate milk varies by manufacturer. One website I looked at listed almost 20 grams of added sugar in chocolate milk, close to five teaspoons. That's not far off from an Oh Henry bar, which was listed with 26.3 grams of sugar.
Mind you, that was in a 57-gram bar. When I went across the street, the Oh Henry bar I found on the shelf was 85 grams. Then again, listings for chocolate milk were for 250-millilitre servings, and the chocolate milk in the fridge was in 250-millilitre bottles.
Once again, grotesque serving sizes come into play here.
After the controversy hit the web page, CBC P.E.I.'s radio morning show brought in nutritionist Jennifer Taylor to comment.
"If you look at the big picture of how children eat, I don't think it's chocolate milk we should be getting all whipped up about," said Taylor.
Taylor said there is clear evidence that only about half of children on P.E.I. are getting enough calcium and vitamin D in their diets. Milk, she said, is the easiest way to supplement that. And if it's chocolate, that little bit of sugar is a small price to pay.
It doesn't hurt that the local dairy has relatively low sugar content in its milk, only about three teaspoons added per cup.
Should children be encouraged to drink chocolate milk?
All News blogs
- Food in times of sorrow
- In spring, a doctor discovered that my grandfather had glioblastoma multiforme, the deadliest and most aggressive primary brain tumour. As he battled the tumour over the following months, it was food that connected the family and allowed him to still 'live' instead of merely survive. Later on,... Continue reading this post
- Going deep in Chicago
- No, I’m not talking the Chicago Cubs, I’m talking Pizzaria Uno, creator of the original deep dish pizza.... Continue reading this post
- Q&A with Khalil Akhtar, host of The Main Ingredient
- The Main Ingredient is one of CBC Radio's new summer programs. It's an inside look on the food we grow, buy and eat. In a Q&A, host Khalil Akhtar took the time to discuss his relationship with food and why... Continue reading this post