CBCnews

Armed standoff ends with surrender

Last Updated: Wednesday, October 21, 2009 | 11:19 PM MT

Tactical police gather Wednesday morning near the Workers' Compensation Board in Edmonton, where a man with a gun was holding hostages. After a standoff that lasted until evening, the man surrendered to police. Tactical police gather Wednesday morning near the Workers' Compensation Board in Edmonton, where a man with a gun was holding hostages. After a standoff that lasted until evening, the man surrendered to police. (Jimmy Jeong/Canadian Press)

A gunman who held eight hostages at the Workers' Compensation Board building in downtown Edmonton surrendered peacefully around 6:30 p.m. Wednesday, police said.

The alleged hostage taker is Patrick Clayton, 38, a carpenter who was out of work because of an injury. Court documents obtained by CBC show a history of drug abuse and financial problems.

When CBC reporter Briar Stewart visited Clayton's home in a highrise building near the University of Alberta, she was able to reach him by buzzing his apartment intercom, which was forwarded to his cellphone. Clayton told Stewart he was at the WCB building and that the media should come down.

CBC has learned Clayton was living on compensation board payments that were cut off just over a week ago.

'Negotiating from the get-go,' police say

A police officer stands guard behind a tree near the Workers' Compensation Board building in downtown Edmonton.A police officer stands guard behind a tree near the Workers' Compensation Board building in downtown Edmonton. (CBC)

The hostages were all released unharmed and taken to police headquarters to ensure they were unharmed, said Insp. Terry Rocchio, immediately following the arrest.

Rocchio gave credit to the police negotiating team for convincing the gunman to surrender. They "were negotiating with him from the get-go," said Rocchio.

During the standoff, a man claiming to be the hostage taker called the CBC Edmonton newsroom to complain about the treatment he received from the WCB. He said he was injured on the job, the WCB had unfairly cut him off his benefits and that he has been unable to work since.

"I've got tax forms here saying that I've lived on $5,000 a year. They cut me off for two years. I went to social services. I was trying to do career development with them because WCB would not retrain me. All they did was give me a f--king floppy disk, type out my resumé and run around the countryside trying to get employment."

"I'm sitting there. Why do I get this treatment? Why does everybody else get treated better than I do. What did I do so wrong?"

He then ended with what sounded like a threat.

"I'm not walking out of here. I'm not going to jail tonight.That's why I'm saying, this is my last stand."

By mid-afternoon, most of the hostages had been freed as the negotiations continued. By early evening, the last two were freed and the gunman surrendered to police

The standoff began Wednesday at around 8:45 a.m. at the office on 107th Street and 99th Ave. One employee who got out of the building told CBC News that a tall bald man had entered the building with a gun and one shot was fired, but no one was injured. Rocchio said there had been conflicting reports about a shot that were part of the ongoing investigation.

About 700 people work in the building, and many of them streamed out Wednesday morning to call friends and relatives to tell them they were OK.

Beth Anne O'Neil, who was on the fifth floor when the incident began, said she and dozens of other people were told by police to stay put and were locked into offices in the building.

"I don't know why we were left in there, but we were put in rooms, all sorts of rumours flying around, and then we just waited until we could get out," O'Neil said. "I've never been in a situation like this before, and I hope to God I never do again."

'People are frustrated': WCB advocate

An advocate for injured workers who worked at the WCB for 27 years, Gail Cumming, told CBC reporter Kim Trynacity she's not surprised at the incident.

"There's a lot of people that are worried about what's happened and can relate to what's happening right now," she said.

"I think people are frustrated and don't feel that they can go to the government for help any more. These people are not being retrained, they're given 12 weeks to find employment after their injuries when they're severely injured, and they're cut off benefits." she said. "These people are at their wit's end and don't know what to do any more."

Leo Cody is an injured worker who came to the standoff area to watch. He said he understands how frustrating dealing with the board can be.

"There are thousands of us out there who are walked on and abused by these people," Cody said. "It's terrible, terrible."

  •  
 

Video

    Related

    Audio

    THE CURRENT: CBC Radio's Gareth Hampshire explains how the gunman contacted the CBC Edmonton newsroom and what was said (Runs: 21:59)
    Play: Real Media »
    INTERVIEW: Gail Cumming, a former Workers' Compensation Board employee, speaks to CBC-TV's David Gerow (Runs: 1:33)
    Play: Real Media »
    INTERVIEW: WCB claimant Leo Cody speaks to CBC Radio's Trish Estabrooks (Runs: 1:50)
    Play: Real Media »
    ARCHIVE: Sept. 24, 2009 — A Quebec man injured on the job in Alberta fights for better compensation (Runs: 1:42)
    Play: Real Media »
    ARCHIVE: Aug. 11, 2005 — Alberta NDP MLA calls for changes to WCB (Runs: 1:03)
    Play: Real Media »

    Video

    Extended video: Insp. Terry Rocchio takes media questions after the gunman surrendered (Runs: 1:57)
    Play: Real Media »
    Play: QuickTime »
    Briar Stewart reports: More about the gunman (Runs: 1:53)
    Play: Real Media »
    Play: QuickTime »
    Kim Trynacity reports: Mounting frustration among WCB claimants (Runs: 2:15)
    Play: Real Media »
    Play: QuickTime »
    ARCHIVE: Dec. 6, 1993 — A hostage crisis at Alberta Workers' Compensation Board building in Calgary (Runs: 1:47)
    Play: Real Media »
    Play: QuickTime »

    Edmonton Headlines

    Alberta RCMP uncover alleged 'chop shop'
    RCMP in Alberta say after a lengthy investigation they've busted an alleged "chop shop" on the Frog Lake First Nation, east of Edmonton.
    Minivan in fatal Alberta crash was stolen Video
    One of the vehicles in a fiery double-fatal crash that occurred after an Alberta RCMP chase was stolen, according to the provincial agency investigating the incident.
    Alberta H1N1 clinics open to everyone on Monday
    Alberta is re-opening its swine flu vaccination clinics to the general public starting Monday.
    Blackhawks roll over Oilers for 6th straight win
    Jonathan Toews had a pair of goals and an assist while Cristobal Huet made 28 saves as Chicago Blackhawks beat the Edmonton Oilers 5-2 for their sixth straight win.
    Tweet about premier a 'lapse in judgment'
    A strategist for the Wildrose Alliance Party has apologized to the premier's office for sending out messages on his Twitter account that made fun of the way Premier Ed Stelmach speaks.

    Canada Headlines

    Disgraced N.S. bishop's replacement named Video
    The Roman Catholic Church has appointed a replacement for Bishop Raymond Lahey, of the Diocese of Antigonish, N.S., who is facing child pornography charges.
    Vancouver Island evacuation order lifted Video
    An evacuation order has been lifted for hundreds of south Vancouver Island residents forced from their homes by flooding.
    Journalists enhance Canadians' freedom: PM
    Prime Minister Stephen Harper urged journalists to "shine light into dark corners" of government affairs during a speech late Saturday, but wouldn't take questions from reporters covering the event.
    4 dead in crash south of Calgary
    RCMP say four people died when two vehicles collided on a stretch of divided highway about 75 kilometres south of Calgary.
    N.B. man recovering after car plunges into culvert
    A New Brunswick man is recovering in hospital after his car plunged into a washed-out culvert near Chipman.

    People who read this also read …

    Top CBCNews.ca Headlines

    Headlines

    McCain argues against Afghanistan exit date Video
    U.S. Senator John McCain says military exit dates and exit strategies in Afghanistan should not even be discussed until NATO gets the upper hand in its fight against Taliban militants.
    U.S. health-care bill clears Senate hurdle
    Democrats united Saturday night to narrowly push historic health-care legislation past a key U.S. Senate hurdle over the opposition of Republicans eager to inflict a punishing defeat on President Barack Obama.
    Disgraced N.S. bishop's replacement named Video
    The Roman Catholic Church has appointed a replacement for Bishop Raymond Lahey, of the Diocese of Antigonish, N.S., who is facing child pornography charges.
    Rocket hits luxury hotel in Afghan capital
    At least two people were hurt when a rocket struck a wall of the heavily guarded Serena Hotel in Kabul, the Interior Ministry says.
    Vancouver Island evacuation order lifted Video
    An evacuation order has been lifted for hundreds of south Vancouver Island residents forced from their homes by flooding.