Controversy continues in Calgary-Montrose as the Alberta Liberals and NDP raise questions about a possible conflict of interest involving the riding's returning officer.
The Conservative government appointed Lynn Warkentin in December to be the returning officer in the northeast riding.
Her husband, Frank, is the chair of the Progressive Conservative party's nomination committee in Calgary-Montrose — a connection, the two opposition leaders say, that warrants the removal of Warkentin from her post.
'There's a potential for a conflict of interest, and I think the returning officer should step aside.'—Alberta NDP Leader Brian Mason
"There's very close ties between the local returning officer and the PC association [in Calgary-Montrose]," said Alberta Liberal Leader Kevin Taft.
"It's wrong. There should not be ties between returning officers and any political party."
Returning officers hire poll workers and ensure election rules are followed. In the rare event of a tie vote, they can actually cast a ballot to break a deadlock.
"This is, by its nature, a position that should be politically neutral," said Lisa Young, a political scientist at the University of Calgary.
Government appoints returning officers
No one is criticizing Warkentin for doing a bad job, but many are concerned about the public's perception.
NDP Leader Brian Mason said returning officers should be appointed by Elections Alberta, not the government.
The legislation that allows the government appointments states returning officers cannot be politically active while in that position — but does not say anything about before or after elections, he said.
"The legislation is far too loose in the first place," said Mason. "There's a potential for a conflict of interest, and I think the returning officer should step aside."
'People can say what they want to say. I have no comment.'—Lynn Warkentin, returning officer
Taft said he plans to write to Alberta's chief electoral officer about the situation in Calgary-Montrose.
"It's like having the referee in a [Calgary] Flames game on the payroll of the opposing team," he said.
However, neither Mason nor Taft could point to an example of a returning officer acting in anything less than an impartial way in recent years.
No conflict-of-interest rules for returning officers
When asked to comment about the concerns raised by the opposition parties, Warkentin told CBC News: "People can say what they want to say. I have no comment."
The Tories would not comment on the situation or say why Warkentin was selected for the job.
"I can't comment on any allegations or speculation," said Jacqueline Roblin, spokeswoman for Elections Alberta. "We don't have any of those facts before us. They're all allegations and speculation."
Roblin said there are no specific rules about conflicts of interest for returning officers, but if it's proven that the officer is not impartial or is not following the rules, he or she can be removed by the chief electoral officer and fined $500.
Calgary-Montrose mired in controversy
On the federal level, the Conservative government's Accountability Act turned over the appointment of returning officers from the government to the chief electoral officer in December 2006.
The northeast riding of Calgary-Montrose has seen much unrest in recent months. The Tories had to appoint a candidate in Montrose after the local riding association refused to hold a nomination meeting because of a prolonged legal dispute with its own party.
Hung Pham, the previous Conservative MLA in Calgary-Montrose, announced in January he was quitting politics, saying he was disenchanted with the way the Tory party handled the fight with the constituency.
Related
Alberta Votes 2008 »
- It's 'Ed's Empire' after Alberta election sweep
- Political observers in Alberta are calling it remarkable and opposition politicians are wondering what hit them after Ed Stelmach guided his Conservative party Monday to one of its biggest majorities ever.
- Low voter turnout in Alberta election being questioned
- As Premier Ed Stelmach and Alberta Conservatives savour their sweeping election victory, some people are raising a nagging concern: why so few people bothered to vote.
- Albertans elect historic 11th straight Tory government
- Voters in Alberta stuck with tried-and-true blue, giving the Progressive Conservative party an unprecedented 11th consecutive majority government in Monday's provincial election.
- Political tide turns in Edmonton
- Alberta Progressive Conservative Leader Ed Stelmach has proven true to his word, putting the "Ed" back in Edmonton.
- Conservatives' Calgary fortress resists change
- The Progressive Conservatives' fortress in Calgary stood strong as the party took 18 of the city's 23 ridings Monday night.
Riding Profiles
More Alberta Votes Headlines »
- It's 'Ed's Empire' after Alberta election sweep
- Political observers in Alberta are calling it remarkable and opposition politicians are wondering what hit them after Ed Stelmach guided his Conservative party Monday to one of its biggest majorities ever.
- Low voter turnout in Alberta election being questioned
- As Premier Ed Stelmach and Alberta Conservatives savour their sweeping election victory, some people are raising a nagging concern: why so few people bothered to vote.
- Albertans elect historic 11th straight Tory government
- Voters in Alberta stuck with tried-and-true blue, giving the Progressive Conservative party an unprecedented 11th consecutive majority government in Monday's provincial election.
- Political tide turns in Edmonton
- Alberta Progressive Conservative Leader Ed Stelmach has proven true to his word, putting the "Ed" back in Edmonton.
- Conservatives' Calgary fortress resists change
- The Progressive Conservatives' fortress in Calgary stood strong as the party took 18 of the city's 23 ridings Monday night.
