CBCBooks on  Twitter CBCBooks on Facebook

Simi Sara describes why she chose Good to a Fault for Canada Reads 2010

It was so easy for me to love Good to a Fault. I sat down by myself, the family was away, on a Saturday afternoon. The house was quiet. I picked it up and started to read and immediately saw traits in Clara that I know most women in Canada could identify with.

When I read a book I generally know within the first couple of chapters how I feel about it. Am I going to have to force myself to finish it? Will I be able to put it down? Where is is it going to fall on my list of books that I love?

The day I started reading Good to a Fault not a lot else got done at my house. In fact, not much got done until a day and a half later — when I'd finished it. I knew this book had me when (SPOILER ALERT) I found myself wishing Clara could keep the kids with her and when I realized that meant that I'd have to be wishing for the death of their mother, I was horrified. What kind of person was I?

That ethical dilemma made me realize what a brilliant job Marina Endicott had done to lure me to that place. Life is not a happy ending. Life is messy. In the best possible way she showed us how that messiness is actually what helps us to grow and learn and love. How could I have known that the journey of a middle-aged woman from the Prairies would be the same that so many of us go through, no matter where we live or what background we come from?

When I was asked to provide a few books as choices for Canada Reads, Good to a Fault was the first one that popped into my head. There were others that I considered, like The Winter Vault by Anne Michaels and The Other Side of the Bridge by Mary Lawson. Sure, Good to a Fault wasn't as well known; in fact, my bookstore had to order it in for me when I asked them for it. But isn't that what Canada Reads is all about? What better way to honour Canadian authors and the publishing industry than by picking a book that many people hadn't heard of or read. Because I am positive that once they do, they will realize what I did — that there is a little Clara in all of us; one that wonders if maybe she should have done things a little differently; one that longs to shake up her world but doesn't know where to start and, most of all, someone who wants to be loved just as she is.


Comments are closed.