Montreal

Montreal flood-zone map for hard-hit Pierrefonds is decades out of date

Most recent map for floodplain along the Rivière des Prairies is from the 1980s

WEA Cda Flooding 20170507

Members of a family are helped with some belongings after being evacuated from their home in the Montreal borough of Pierrefonds on May 7. (Graham Hughes/Canadian Press)

 shares

 

Over the past few weeks of flooding in the Montreal area, one of the hardest-hit neighbourhoods has been in Pierrefonds on the Rivière des Prairies. CBC News has learned that the floodplain map for that area of the city's north shore is decades out of date.

The most recent complete map for flood zones along the Rivière des Prairies that CBC was able to obtain is from the 1980s.

It's so old that it has been archived by Quebec's Environment Ministry, intended for historical reference rather than planning purposes.

Compare this outdated map to the actual flooding on an eastern sector of Pierrefonds near Saint-Jean Boulevard:

Historical water levels of the Lake of Two Mountains compared to today.

(Hélène Simard/CBC)

CBC contacted the City of Montreal to ask for an explanation. 

City spokesperson Jacques-Alain Lavallée said that a new map based on 2006 data was in production.

When asked why it has taken so long to update, Lavallée said that the maps are the responsibility of the Communauté métropolitaine de Montréal (CMM), known in English as the Montreal Metropolitan Community.

Mayor Denis Coderre chairs the CMM.

In a news conference on Friday, Coderre said that he's asked for the creation of a working group to address climate change and urban planning. 

2006 data not incorporated into map

A hydrology analyst with the Quebec Environment Ministry explained to CBC that while the ministry produced new data in 2006, it appears only the maps for the Miles Îles River and the Lake of Two Mountains were updated — not the Rivière des Prairies.

Urban planners rely on accurate flood mapping to advise cities on where to build — and where not to build — critical institutions such as hospitals and long-term care homes.

isabelle thomas professor urban planning universite de montreal

Isabelle Thomas, an urban planning professor at the University of Montreal, says if planners rely on maps from the 1980s it makes it difficult to advise cities on how to develop properly. (CBC)

Isabelle Thomas, an urban planning professor at the University of Montreal, said that when she first started to work in Quebec, she was surprised at the gap.

"If you look at what has happened in Montreal in the last two weeks, some institutions, even hospitals, had to be evacuated," she said.

'If you look in Europe, you have these maps. If you look in the U.S., you have these maps.'

- Isabelle Thomas, Urban planning professor

"Obviously, if these flood maps are from the ... '80s, how can we map adaptation?" Thomas asked, adding that climate change creates even more uncertainty.

"If you look in Europe, you have these maps. If you look in the U.S., you have these maps. Even in New Orleans."

Flood data vital to development

Developers also rely on up-to-date information from the government to make sure their waterfront structures are protected from flood risks.

BleuMaree condos pierrefonds

Developers say they rely on up-to-date information when they build waterfront buildings, such as the BleuMarée condominiums in Pierrefonds, shown here. (Google Maps)

Pat Carbone was in charge of sales and promotion for the BleuMarée Condominiums, which were completed in 2014 and overlook the Rivière des Prairies in Pierrefonds.

"It's vital, because if you don't have the right information, you don't build at the right level, [then] you have damage," Carbone said.

During the flooding of the past two weeks, the building has remained dry, even though another building just three doors down had to be evacuated.

'If you don't have the right information, you don't build at the right level, [then] you have damage.' - Pat Carbone, Montreal condo developer

Carbone said that's because his team took extra precaution when they built in that area.

"We built a couple feet higher than the level that the city and the Ministry of Environment had established."

Should Montreal consider a 'managed retreat?'

Jason Thistlethwaite, assistant professor at the University of Waterloo's faculty of environment, said all levels of government need to be looking at ways to encourage developers and homeowners to move farther away from flood risk zones.

But to do that, they have to know where those vulnerable areas are.

"The government needs to come out and say, 'Look, here's where the flood risk areas are,' and that gives some leverage to municipalities to go against the developer and say, 'We think that development in this area isn't worth it.'"

He said the U.S. actively uses a strategy known as a "managed retreat" to encourage people to move away from high-risk areas.

The idea, he explained, is that governments notify people that they have two options: Sell their home to the government at market value and move to a safer area, or remain, but accept that they'll be on their own to defend against flooding. 

"The benefits of preventing a flood before it happens far exceed the costs of the damage after a flood," he said. 

More On This Story

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.

More from CBC News

Tell us what you think