Canadians appear to be more hateful online. Here's what you can do about it
Marketplace report suggests hateful language by Canadians online up by 600 per cent over last year
The internet can be a pretty intolerant place, and it may be getting worse.
An analysis of Canada's online behaviour commissioned by CBC's Marketplace suggests a 600 per cent jump in the past year in how often Canadians use language online that's racist, Islamophobic, sexist or otherwise intolerant.
"That's a dramatic increase in the number of people feeling comfortable to make those comments," James Rubec, content strategist for media marketing company Cision, told Marketplace.
Cision scanned social media, blogs and comments threads between November 2015 and November 2016 for slurs and intolerant phrases like "ban Muslims," "sieg heil" or "white genocide." They found that terms related to white supremacy jumped 300 per cent, while terms related to Islamophobia increased 200 per cent.
"It might not be that there are more racists in Canada than there used to be, but they feel more emboldened. And maybe that's because of the larger racist sentiments that are coming out of the United States," Rubec said.
So when you see hateful speech online, what can you do about it?
Marketplace's Asha Tomlinson joined journalist and cultural critic Septembre Anderson and University of Ontario Institute of Technology sociologist Barbara Perry, whose work focuses on hate crimes, to share strategies and tips for confronting intolerance online.
Watch the Marketplace investigation "The Trump Effect: Has It Come To Canada?" tonight on TV and online at 8 p.m. ET.
If the person making hurtful comments is a friend, message them privately about it. Calling them out publicly can backfire.
"If someone's defensive, you're not going to reach them," Anderson says. "So sometimes it's best just to call in. Send them a private message, text them."
If it's a stranger saying something cruel, feel free to respond in kind.
But that doesn't mean getting all-out social media war.
"Not shaming, but clapping back," Anderson says. "Something really witty that proves your point ... basically, I'm going to do a mic drop; I'm going to say this one thing, then the conversation is over."
"There's value in that to empower the person who is being attacked," Anderson says. "Sometimes people need to feel powerful again."
Shut it down
Ending the conversation is key.
"Oftentimes, we feel so drawn in, we get so emotionally invested. It's just not healthy for everybody. So you got to know when to fold 'em, know when to back out," says Anderson.
It helps to have a personal guideline.
"I have a two-comment policy," says Anderson. "I'm only responding two times, that's it."
Not everyone who says something hurtful is necessarily coming from a place of hate, Perry says. If you want to have a conversation without getting into a fight, try starting with a question.
"Where does that come from? Why is that your stance of the issue? Why is that how you understand this problem?" she says.
"Having a conversation that starts with questions, I think, is really important because then you're not starting with accusations or the presumption that they're being racist."
Drop some knowledge
Once you better understand their perspective, try sharing yours.
"Some people, they really want to understand," says Perry. "So that's when you can take those opportunities to really share some of that knowledge, share some of that experience that you have."
If that's too much to ask, Anderson suggests replying with links to useful articles, information and writers.
"It also ends the conversation," she says. "I've given you all the answers you need with all the information you need, so stop bothering me."
It shouldn't always fall on marginalized people to defend themselves from online hate, says Anderson.
"When we talk about bystander intervention, it's often a conversation about what happens in public when you see an interaction that's negative," she says. "There are lots of ways for bystander intervention to work online."
That could mean jumping into the fray, documenting the abuse, or reporting the abuser.
Or it could be as simple as liking the victim's replies.
"Merely liking a comment shows you I'm here, I see what happens, I support you, you're not alone," Anderson says. "Often, that's so powerful."
But no matter how diligent you are, the internet can still be a cesspool of racism, sexism and intolerance — so don't forget to unplug now and then, whether for a couple minutes or a couple weeks.
"Take a breather and get a mug of tea, have a shot if you need one, go for a walk, do a yoga flow," Anderson says. "Do what you would normally do to make yourself feel good. I know people are like, 'It's online, its not real' and you may feel silly doing it, but you know what? It's not silly. Take care of yourself."
Popular in News
1 730 reading now Gord Downie's brothers open up about his childhood and legacy
- 2 607 reading now 'The old guard in revolt': Why ex-presidents are violating code of silence to fight 'Trumpism'
- 3 357 reading now Dalhousie student faces disciplinary action over Canada 150 post
- 4 214 reading now How super are those pricey 'superfoods'? Marketplace puts 3 of them to the test
- 5 144 reading now 2 Winnipeg officers put on leave in connection with fatal hit and run involving constable