Lesson Plan: For Teachers: Write a Pipeline Inquiry Report
Have students imagine that they were
going to gather information in order to make a recommendation on the issue of
the Northern Pipeline. Ask them to brainstorm what approach they would take to
gather the information. Then ask: How would you factor in the biases of
interviewees in your decision making process?
As a class, summarize the Berger report and its recommendations. (If students have not completed the activity Who Gains from the Pipeline? they can complete it now, or they can view the clips on the topic The Berger Pipeline Inquiry on the CBC Digital Archives website to find out the recommendations of the report.)
Outline the Opportunity
In teams or individually, students should develop a plan for gathering facts, opinions, and economic and political considerations regarding the Northern Pipeline. Using their plan, they should create an organizer on which they can gather their information. Then direct them to the topic The Berger Pipeline Inquiry on the CBC Digital Archives website and have them complete their organizer. Students should use their information to create their own report and recommendations about the pipeline.
Revisit and Reflect
Have each group share its report with the class. Students should compare and contrast reports, noting whether groups agreed with one another, whether they agreed with Berger, in which areas they disagreed, whether there were areas where all reports were unanimous, and so on. Students should explain the reasons for the similarities and differences.
Students can estimate the time it
would have taken to prepare the real report, and how much money might have been
charged to the government to do so. They can research this information on the
topic site, then discuss in small groups whether Berger spent too much time or
money on this report.
Interested student may wish to find other examples of government funded reports, and analyze the time and money spent and the effect of the recommendations. How do these reports compare to the Berger Report?