Lesson Plan: Position Paper: Is the Pill Safe?
Birth control is a sensitive issue
for many reasons, and there are many opinions on the subject. The use of the
birth control pill raises the issue of health and safety, and students will
address this issue during this activity.
Be sure to review with students the key elements of a position paper. You might also consider qualifying the term 'safe.'
Students will write a position paper about whether or not they believe the birth control pill is safe. They will first review the clips on the topic The Birth Control Pill, on the CBC Digital Archives website, ending with the clip "The most conclusive study on the pill declares it safe". Students can do further research using the internet and any other relevant resources. From their research, students should decide which position they support, and then write a 750 to 1000 word essay on whether or not the birth control pill is safe to use.
Students should take extensive notes
as they research, and keep accurate records of sources consulted and cited.
Students will work individually on this paper.
There are many online resources available for this assignment. Direct students toward government and health-care based websites, and away from sites sponsored by commercial corporations. Senior students should have the ability to discern, with support from their teacher, what sites are credible and what sites are not.
Hold an informal discussion with students and allow them to share what they learned through their research, what position they chose to support, and why they chose that position.Download PDF