Duplessis: Charbonneau et Le Chef
Maurice Duplessis's death was a rare historical marker, forever discussed in terms of before and after. Before his death, the province basked in the postwar boom but strikers were punished, communists were hounded and the province's resources were sold to American big business. After his death, the province rallied its way into modernity with the not so Quiet Revolution. But over the past fifty years, historians and Quebecers have been constantly re-evaluating Duplessis and have drawn no certain conclusions.
In this Cross-Country Checkup excerpt, one exasperated caller recalls the strike and says that the play portrays Le Chef too kindly. "To the end of my life, 'til I die," caller Andrée Ouellet says, "I'm going to fight against the National Union."
• Premier Maurice Duplessis, who was decidedly anti-union, sided with the American owners who ran the mines in the province's Eastern Townships. Duplessis rallied the Catholic Church to his side in disapproving of the strike. But the strike movement gained momentum when the Archbishop of Montreal, Joseph Charbonneau, sided with the union.
• The strike continued until Rev. Maurice Roy, Archbishop of Quebec, broke the violent standoff and mediated a settlement on July 1, 1949. The strikers won a five-cent per hour raise, two supplemental days of paid holidays and minor improvements in their vacation package. No improvements were made concerning the health and safety conditions in the mines. Asbestos was later linked to killer diseases such as lung cancer, asbestosis (scarring of the lungs) and mesothelioma.
• At the conclusion of the strike, Archbishop Charbonneau hastily left Montreal for Victoria, B.C.
• Rumours abounded, as reported in the Feb. 20, 1950, edition of Time magazine: "The news broke over Canada's biggest (955,000 person) archdiocese like a stroke of midwinter lightning. But far from dispelling the cloud of rumors, it stirred up fresh ones. Among the most persistent: that the archbishop had really been eased out, partly at the instigation of Quebec's highhanded, labor-hating Premier Maurice Duplessis. The two men had clashed sharply when Archbishop Charbonneau and the local clergy sided with members of the Canadian and Catholic Confederation of Labor in the bitter Asbestos strike even after the strikers barricaded the town and fought Duplessis' provincial police with clubs. Inevitably the two had also found themselves on opposite sides of the Montreal teachers' strike, and there had been differences over Charbonneau's administration of the university."
. Neither Duplessis nor Charbonneau publicly discussed the issue. Charbonneau died in Victoria in 1959.
• According to historian Robert Rumilly, Duplessis had nothing to do with Charbonneau's exile to Victoria. Rumilly said that the church hierarchy ordered the resignation because of Charbonneau's administrative ineptitude and character. (Globe and Mail, June 9, 1972)
. John Thomas McDonough, an Ontario-born former Dominican priest, wrote Charbonneau et Le Chef. After its English-language debut on CBC Radio, the play was staged in French at Quebec City's Théâtre du Trident. The play had a successful run of 293 performances before a total audience of 276,634.
Program: Cross Country Checkup
Broadcast Date: June 30, 1968
Guest(s): Andrée Ouellet
Host: Betty Shapiro
Panellist: Evelyne Dumas, George Johnston
Last updated: September 17, 2013
Page consulted on December 6, 2013
All Clips from this Topic
The outspoken Quebec premier takes on his critics and fights for provi...
Even on his deathbed, Maurice Duplessis manages his image.
John Diefenbaker eulogizes Maurice Duplessis.
Friends, political enemies and contemporaries weigh in on Duplessis's ...
Meet the man who took on Maurice Duplessis and won.
A new play re-examines the 1949 Asbestos strike.
Did Premier Duplessis run a corrupt office?
Conrad Black and Léandre Bergeron debate Duplessis's legacy.
Friend of the poor, protector of the sick - locals remember Maurice Du...
An evaluation of Premier Duplessis as a "crusader."
To mixed reaction, the statue of Maurice Duplessis is put back on disp...
Cartoonist Robert LaPalme chats about his favourite political target.
The Union Nationale party folds in 1989.
Forty years after his death, Canadians reconsider Duplessis's legacy.
Maurice Duplessis's death was a rare historical marker, forever discus...