Métis call for Riel's pardon
Who was Louis Riel? The Métis leader commanded two rebellions in western Canada and was tried, convicted and hanged for treason in 1885. Until well into the 20th century Riel was regarded as "misguided and impetuous" at best and a psychotic traitor at worst. But in the 1960s Riel's image began to turn around. Today most Canadians, particularly the Métis, have reclaimed him as a heroic patriot, founder of Manitoba and a Father of Confederation.
• While on the Supreme Court, Hall was a staunch defender of aboriginal rights. In 1968 he also played a key role in the federal implementation of universal health care.
• On July 25, 1978, the Association of Métis and Non-Status Indians of Saskatchewan passed a resolution at Batoche. The group believed that "Riel was dealt with unjustly by an incompetent government which made him a scapegoat for its own failings."
• The resolution read, in part: "Be it resolved that the government of Canada. act to right these wrongs against Riel and the whole Métis nation, by granting at this late date a posthumous pardon to Riel."
• Among the group's arguments for a pardon were:
- Riel believed he was right under international law;
- he did not act for personal gain;
- he personally committed no illegal act in Red River or Batoche;
- he armed his people only as a self-defence measure
- violence that did occur happened more by accident than design;
- he did not receive a fair trial due to prejudice;
- the judge ignored the jury's call for clemency.
• Under Canadian law, the federal cabinet can grant a pardon to any person convicted of committing a criminal offence. Once a pardon is granted, that person is deemed to have never committed the crime.
• Pardons are granted on two bases: one, that a person is innocent, and this is established and admitted by the Crown; two, that special considerations entitle the person to a pardon. In this case, guilt or innocence is not at issue.
• By 1989 Métis groups had switched tactics. They no longer asked for Riel's pardon, but instead had passed a resolution asking the federal government to recognize Riel as a Father of Confederation. Métis leader Tony Belcourt said they were not asking for a pardon because that presumed guilt on Riel's part.
• This argument hinged on the fact that Riel was loyal to the Queen, and therefore could not have been guilty of treason - the crime for which he was convicted.
• In 1996 Bloc Québécois MP Suzanne Tremblay put forward a private member's bill in the House of Commons. It called for the revocation of Riel's conviction for treason.
• Tremblay's bill was defeated on Dec. 10, 1996, by 112 votes to 103.
• In 2004 the Calgary Herald said more than 25 bills seeking to re-evaluate Riel's status had been introduced over the years.
• Prime Minister Paul Martin vowed to re-examine the Riel case in early 2004. However, the Métis National Council did not support the effort. "Mr. Riel, to us, is a hero and a martyr," said MNC president Clement Chartier. "It's not going to really change any of that if he is pardoned or exonerated."
• Chartier said the government should instead seek to work with Métis people on some of their present concerns. Among these were establishing a land base and gaining the right to self-determination.
Program: The National
Broadcast Date: Nov. 17, 1978
Guest: Emmett Hall
Host: George McLean
Reporter: Bill Gerald
Last updated: October 30, 2013
Page consulted on November 21, 2014
All Clips from this Topic
Saskatchewan Métis are reluctant to mark Canada's Centennial by re-ena...
A CBC reporter disputes a Manitoba man's assertion that Riel deserves ...
The new Louis Riel Society calls for a statue of Riel at the provincia...
The Métis nation holds an annual summer festival to reclaim the site o...
A former Supreme Court judge supports a re-evaluation of the decision ...
Historians and Métis alike are unhappy about the depiction of Riel in ...
Peter Gzowski asks a panel of Canadians to rule on a commission of inq...
On the centennial of the Battle of Batoche, Canadians hold deeply dive...
As It Happens hears the sad story of Riel's secretary and would-be bio...
Métis leader Tony Belcourt argues Riel should be named one of Canada's...
An Ontario legion refuses to give up the bell of Batoche, captured by ...
The war trophy is stolen from an Ontario legion hall and nobody seems ...
After 122 years of provincehood, Manitoba officially recognizes Louis ...
Riel believed he was a prophet of the new world, but a biographer says...
The provincial legislature unveils a new, dignified statue of Riel to ...
An exhibition shows artists' interpretations and depictions of Riel an...
Métis leaders criticize a CBC Newsworld retrial of Riel.
An Alberta historian thinks she knows where Riel went after fleeing Ma...
Louis Riel is the star of a bestselling comic-strip biography.
Just over 106 years after Louis Riel was hanged for treason, the House...