Parizeau poses the question
"À la prochaine fois!" ("Until next time!") promised René Lévesque after the 1980 Quebec referendum. Fifteen years later, on Oct. 30, 1995, Quebec and the rest of Canada faced that "next time" as Quebecers decided whether to separate from Canada. Though they voted to stay by the narrowest of margins, the referendum provoked questions about Canadian identity and Quebec's place in Confederation. CBC Archives relives a period when this country very nearly split apart.
"Do you agree that Quebec should become sovereign after having made a formal offer to Canada for a new economic and political partnership within the scope of the bill respecting the future of Quebec and of the agreement signed on June 12, 1995?"
. It was introduced on the same day as Bill One, also known as the Sovereignty Bill, which established Oct. 30, 1995, as the date for the provincewide referendum.
. The bill, along with a "Declaration of Sovereignty", was first unveiled on Sept. 6 during a private gathering at the Grand Théâtre de Québec. The emotional declaration was penned by a team of Quebec intellectuals and writers, including Gilles Vigneault, Marie Laberge, sociologist Fernand Dumont, journalist Jean-François Lisée and lawyers Andrée Lajoie and Henri Brun.
. It read in part: "The time has come to reap the fields of history. The time has come at last to harvest what has been sown for us by four hundred years of men and women and courage, rooted in the soil and now returned to it."
. Federalist leaders argued that the rambling nature of the referendum question was an effort by the premier to confuse voters. Quebec Liberal leader Daniel Johnson said "The PQ government believes that they can trick Quebecers into voting Yes."
. The question made no reference to Quebec as an independent country, instead talking about a new negotiated partnership with Canada.
. Any negotiations would be carried out under the terms laid out in Bill One, which boasted some 27 different articles.
. The June 12 agreement mentioned at the end of the question referred to the coalition of Quebec's three separatist parties. Under that agreement, if the negotiations failed after a one-year period, Quebec's National Assembly would have the power to separate from the rest of Canada.
. Frank McKenna, the premier of New Brunswick, said a Yes vote under these conditions would leave rest of the country to "negotiate with a knife at our throat."
. Critics pointed out that the 1995 referendum was significantly different from the 1980 referendum put forward by René Lévesque. As envisioned by Lévesque, the referendum involved two possible votes: one for a mandate to negotiate a new deal with the federal government, and a second vote to ratify any deal that was reached.
. The 1980 referendum question read as follows: "The Government of Quebec has made public its proposal to negotiate a new agreement with the rest of Canada, based on the equality of nations; this agreement would enable Quebec to acquire the exclusive power to make its laws, administer its taxes and establish relations abroad - (continued)
(continued) in other words, sovereignty - and at the same time, to maintain with Canada an economic association including a common currency; any change in political status resulting from these negotiations will be submitted to the people through a referendum; ON THESE TERMS, DO YOU AGREE TO GIVE THE GOVERNMENT OF QUEBEC THE MANDATE TO NEGOTIATE THE PROPOSED AGREEMENT BETWEEN QUEBEC AND CANADA?"
. Pierre Paradis, the Liberal house leader in Quebec's National Assembly, described the 1995 question as cloudy and dishonest during an interview on CBC radio's As It Happens. He argued that voting Yes in the referendum would be like handing Jacques Parizeau a "blank cheque".
. Sovereigntist scholar Daniel Latouche, who helped pen 1980's question, contended the new question was a vast improvement. To hear them discuss the issue go to the additional clip 'The Quebec Referendum question'.
Program: The National
Broadcast Date: Sept. 7, 1995
Guest(s): Jean Charest, Daniel Johnson, Preston Manning, Frank McKenna, Jacques Parizeau, Lucienne Robillard, Roy Romanow, Clyde Wells
Host: Peter Mansbridge
Reporter: Tom Kennedy, Jason Moscovitz
Last updated: October 30, 2012
Page consulted on September 10, 2014
All Clips from this Topic
Newly elected Quebec Premier Jacques Parizeau promises a referendum on...
Three of Quebec's political heavyweights join forces to promote a new ...
The Yes side launches a hard sell for sovereignty while the No side bi...
Jacques Parizeau unveils his blueprint for Quebec sovereignty which in...
The Canadian dollar takes a dive after the world's financial markets c...
Jean Chrétien says separatists will need more than a simple majority i...
The Yes side legally launches its campaign for the Oct. 30 referendum.
Three days before the fateful vote, a huge crowd converges in Montreal...
With the Yes and No camps in a dead heat voters cast their ballots on ...
A razor-thin victory for the No side prompts relief, resentment and on...
Bloc Québécois leader Lucien Bouchard delivers his concession speech t...
Prime Minister Jean Chrétien responds to the razor-thin No victory in ...
The Quebec Liberal leader addresses No supporters in Montreal.
In 1995 the controversial former Quebec premier looks back at the day ...
The real divide in the referendum result seems to be between rural and...
A new bill in Parliament seeks to define the terms of future referendu...
"À la prochaine fois!" (Until next time!) promised René Lévesque after...