Profit dispute over Anne of Green Gables
One hundred years ago, Anne of Green Gables introduced readers to one of the most enduring characters in fiction and launched Canada's most lucrative literary franchise. The heartwarming story of the plucky red-headed orphan has gone on to sell hundreds of millions of copies and become the basis for an unprecedented television phenomenon. But behind the fictional and feisty Anne Shirley lurked the often-tormented life of author Lucy Maud Montgomery. CBC Archives takes a look at the life, death and lasting legacy of the woman who created Anne.
This CBC Television report looks at the claims and counterclaims in this legal tug-of-war that will eventually land both in court.
• The contract also stipulated that the heirs would be paid 10 per cent of the net profits in perpetuity on all rights from any adaptations. It stated that the Macdonalds would be permitted to audit the company's books.
• The family, led by daughter-in-law Ruth Macdonald and granddaughter Kate Butler Macdonald, claim they made more than 40 requests for an independent audit of Sullivan Entertainment's books throughout the 1990s and were turned down each time. In July 1999 they held a news conference in Toronto where they publicly expressed their frustration and provided details of their fight.
• "We've been stonewalled too long," Macdonald Butler told the Globe and Mail.
• Kevin Sullivan rejected the family's accusations and launched a $55-million defamation suit against the heirs and their lawyer, Marian Hebb.
• A lawyer for Sullivan said his client had offered to take the dispute to an independent arbitrator, but the family "pulled the plug on that process and went public."
• Sullivan insisted that although the films were a hit, he had yet to make a profit from them, citing a complex system of co-producers and investors. In fact, in the early 1990s he sued a number of PBS stations in the United States for $2.5 million in unpaid broadcasting fees.
• Sullivan claimed the family's press conference forced him to postpone a plan to take his entertainment company public, costing him millions of dollars.
• During the five-year court battle that resulted, accusations flew, including one that claimed Sullivan challenged the relationship of Ruth Macdonald to L.M. Montgomery.
• In January 2004 the defamation lawsuit was thrown out of court by a Toronto judge.
• In a 38-page ruling, Justice Jean MacFarland called Sullivan "one of the most evasive witnesses I have encountered ... When cross-examined, he could not answer a question directly. The most simple of questions elicited a long, complex and essentially evasive response in many, many instances."
• In September 2004 Sullivan appealed the ruling, claiming that the judge had made more than dozen errors in her ruling. The application has yet to go to before a court (2005).
Program: The National
Broadcast Date: July 6, 1999
Guest(s): Marian Hebb, Kate Macdonald Butler
Host: Diana Swain
Reporter: Norman Hermant
Last updated: October 29, 2012
Page consulted on September 10, 2014
All Clips from this Topic
Creators of the popular Anne of Green Gables: The Musical reflect on i...
A reading from Montgomery's private journals.
A behind-the-scenes look at how Anne of Green Gables became the most w...
How Lucy Maud Montgomery's young life was changed forever by a family ...
At long last Montgomery gets married and moves to Ontario to begin her...
Montgomery's heirs crack down on unlicensed Anne of Green Gables merch...
A guided tour of the land that inspired Anne of Green Gables.
The story of how "Ania z Zielonego Wzgorza" became a popular hero in P...
Friends and family share their personal memories of Lucy Maud Montgome...
Lucy Maud Montgomery pursues her writing career in turn-of-the-century...
Montgomery lives out her final years as family troubles, her own menta...
Montgomery's heirs take their fight over profits with television produ...
An expert on Montgomery reacts to a theory that Anne of Green Gables c...
Scholars and fans gather in P.E.I. for an international conference ded...
A look at Japan's 50-year obsession with all things Anne.
A look inside the final volume of Montgomery's personal, and painful, ...
Over 100 years ago, Anne of Green Gables introduced readers to one of ...