British Columbia

B.C. eyes stricter distracted driving penalties as collisions surge

Distracted drivers killing more people than drunk drivers, B.C. solicitor general says

CBC News

September 25, 2017

Since fines don't seem to deter drivers from using their phones, some suggest shaming can change social attitudes. (LM Otero/Associated Press)

The B.C. government is considering imposing stricter penalties on distracted drivers as collisions across the province continue to surge.

B.C. Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General Mike Farnworth says the province is keeping a close eye on Ontario, where new penalties have been introduced to reduce collisions — including a $50,000 fine and up to two years jail time aimed at distracted drivers who kill.

ADVERTISEMENT

"Deaths due to distracted driving are now overtaking those from alcohol-related [collisions]," Farnworth told CBC News.

"You have to enforce the rules that we've had, hit people in the pocket book, education campaign, and, in the case of distracted driving that causes death or serious bodily harm, look at what Ontario is doing."

According to ICBC, one in four deaths on B.C. roads involve distracted driving.

Current penalties in B.C. include a $368 traffic violation ticket that also carries four penalty points for each offence. Repeat offenders can also be slapped with 90-day prohibitions.

Morality vs. self-interest

Criminal defence lawyer Paul Doroshenko says increased fines, however, don't necessarily deter people from breaking the law.

"The whole idea here is to deter people — we just don't want people to pick up their phones and be distracted," said Doroshenko. "The problem that I see is that we never see the follow-through on enforcement."

According to ICBC, one in four deaths on B.C. roads involve distracted driving. (Chris Ensing/CBC)

Doroshenko says increased penalties don't necessarily deter drivers from using their phones behind the wheel. 

"People don't think about the morality of the crime, they think about their self-interest. And their self-interest is not getting caught."

He says having more officers on the ground to actively seek out distracted drivers and enforce penalties would prove more effective.

"The governments are great at passing the laws, but not great at giving the police the money they need to enforce the laws.

With files from CBC's B.C. Almanac

Start the day smarter
Get the CBC News Morning Brief, the essential news you need delivered to your inbox